Pixel Binning vs OverSampling: Which is better?

Pixel binning and oversampling are two techniques that are used to produce lower resolution images from higher resolution sensors. They have different advantages and disadvantages depending on the situation and the desired output quality.

What is Pixel Binning?

Pixel binning combines adjacent pixels on the sensor into larger pixels, which reduces the resolution but increases the signal-to-noise ratio and the dynamic range. Pixel binning can be done either on the sensor level or on the image processor level. Pixel binning is simpler and faster than oversampling, but it can also introduce some artifacts such as loss of detail, color moire, and aliasing. Pixel binning is often used in low-light situations, where noise reduction is more important than resolution. Pixel binning is also used in some video modes, where high frame rates are required.

What is Oversampling?

Oversampling captures the full resolution of the sensor and then downsamples it to a lower resolution using a sophisticated algorithm. Oversampling preserves more detail and sharpness than pixel binning, and also reduces noise and moire. Oversampling is more computationally intensive and slower than pixel binning, but it can produce higher quality images. Oversampling is often used in situations where resolution is not the main priority, but image quality is. Oversampling is also used in some video modes, where high dynamic range and color accuracy are required.

Pixel Binning vs Oversampling, explained

To reiterate, pixel binning and oversampling are both ways of reducing the resolution of a high-resolution sensor, but they have different effects on the image quality. Pixel binning is faster and simpler, but it can degrade the image quality in some aspects. Oversampling is slower and more complex, but it can enhance the image quality in some aspects. The choice of which technique to use depends on the trade-off between speed, resolution, and quality.

History of Oversampling in mobile phones

Oversampling is a photography process that has been around since the Nokia 808 PureView, which used its 41-megapixel camera to combine several sensor pixels into 5-megapixel photos. That was the first implementation of oversampling in a mobile phone camera. The Nokia 808 was released in 2012. The technique was called pixel oversampling back then.

The Nokia 808 PureView went on to become a legend among camera phones, leaving every competitor in the dust, and continued to be the best cameraphone for years after its release.

Today in 2021, oversampling has gone mainstream and is being implemented in smartphones on all sides. Every time you see a smartphone camera with a huge megapixel figure, e.g. 64 megapixels, 108 megapixels, 200 megapixels, you are likely looking at a camera using image oversampling. Most of them produce photos of no more than 12 to 27 megapixels in size. That happens by combining three or four pixels together.

Pixel binning or oversampling first appeared in a phone camera in 2012
Oversampling first appeared in the Nokia 808 PureView’s camera in 2012

To reiterate, pixel oversampling technology takes a higher resolution sensor and combines multiple pixels to produce fewer super pixels, for better photo quality. As already mentioned, the Nokia 808 PureView was the forerunner of the current crop of Android smartphones using the technology. I owned one. But I have also owned and reviewed a few other modern smartphones that use the technique. My Xiaomi Mi Note 10 Pro, itself another sterling camera phone, uses pixel oversampling. It has a 108-megapixel camera that produces 27 MP photos. TECNO Camon 18 Premier has a 64-megapixel camera that produces 16-megapixel photos by default.

Samsung Galaxy S22 Ultra’s 108-megapixel camera produces 12-megapixel photos, also thanks to pixel oversampling. The technique is quite widely used now.

How does Pixel Oversampling make photography better?

By processing a large number of pixels into smaller pixels in an image, a phone camera can collect more light from the scene. Light is the life and soul of photography. Every photographer knows this. The more light a camera – any camera – can squeeze out of a scene, the better the photos it will produce, all other things being equal.

For this reason, pixel oversampling makes for better, less noisy, photography, especially low-light photography. Most phones that have pixel oversampling can also take photos in full resolution. That means, you can take 108-megapixel photos with the Galaxy S22 Ultra. However, you will get overall better photo quality when you use the camera in its default oversampling mode and shoot 12 MP images.

How does Pixel Binning make photography better?

In pixel binning, the camera combines information from adjacent pixels on an image sensor to create a single “superpixel.” This results in better low-light images, reduced image noise, enhanced dynamic range, and better color accuracy.

Pixel binning and Oversampling in modern cell phones

There are scores of phones, mostly premium flagships and upper mid-range models, that use pixel binning or oversampling in their cameras. You are not likely to see these technologies used in entry-level and budget phones, perhaps not until they trickles down, as almost all advanced technologies do.

We will see more and more cameraphones process pixels differently. It isn’t about the megapixels; it is about what those cameras are doing with them, and image oversampling and pixel binning are a key part of that equation. Just so there is no mixup, there are other factors that determine photo quality. The megapixel count and image processing are not the only factors. But they do count.

Apple’s iPhone 13, for example, has a 12-megapixel camera; there is no pixel binning or oversampling technology involved. But while the lens has fewer pixels, each pixel is large, allowing for the lens to collect large amounts of light. In other words, Apple has achieved the same results without using image oversampling or binning. And if what we have seen from reviews is anything to go by, the iPhone 13 camera does a better job than the Galaxy S22 Ultra‘s. I shared this bit to illustrate the point about the megapixel count not being the holy grail.

Yet, the following year, the iPhone 14 Pro and 14 Pro Max both showed up with larger megapixel cameras that use pixel binning. And this has continued. As mentioned earlier, once you see fairly larger megapixel counts, chances are that pixel binning or oversampling is involved.

Pixel Binning vs OverSampling: Verdict

When it comes to these two related camera technologies, oversampling is the better one; it produces much better image quality. However, pixel binning is the more commonly used technology.

Leave a Comment

Home | About Us | Contact Us | Privacy
Copyright © 2014 – 2024 MobilityArena. All rights reserved.